Ultraviolet light vs Ozone - The true costs
The following table
illustrates the difference in purchase and running costs of UV
sterilisation and ozone
treatment based on a typical 25 meter exercise pool (450 m³ volume, 2
hour turnover, high peak bather load).
Item |
Description
- Ozone plant |
Cost-
Ozone |
Description
-UV plant |
Cost
- UV |
UV
SAVING |
Capital
Costs |
|
£ |
|
£ |
£ |
Equipment |
Ozone
generator unit |
10,000 |
Top
spec, fully automatic with wipers, strainer, monitor and full
controls |
23,500 |
|
Filters,
mixer vessels degasser etc |
Say,
2x2.4m dia vessels + mixer vessel |
22,500 |
Not
required |
0 |
|
Installation,
labour & fittings |
Extra
for ozone plant |
7,500 |
Simple
3 valve bypass system only |
4,500 |
|
Plantroom
space. Footprint area. |
Overall
area required: 2 x vessels - 15 m², ozone generator 6 m²,
mixer pumps and pipework 5 m² |
13,000 |
Equipment
footprint = 1.7x0.6 m, allow 3.5 by 1.1 meters for full access |
1,925 |
|
Safety
detector |
Ozone
detector - ozone very poisonous, 0.1 PPM maximum safe level |
2,000 |
No
health risks associated with UV |
|
|
Total
Capital Costs |
|
55,000 |
|
29,925 |
CAPITAL
SAVING 25,075 |
Operating
Costs |
|
|
|
|
|
Power |
Typical
consumption inc pumps 10kW |
2,700 |
2.2 kVA |
600 |
|
Annual
maintenance costs inc spares |
Typical
annual contract costs, inc dielectric tubes from major supplier |
5,500 |
Service
contract inc lamp replacement as required, seals and labour |
2,750 |
|
Ozone
detector recalibration |
|
500 |
n/a |
0 |
|
Filter
vessels |
Epoxy
lining £15,000 every five years |
3,000 |
n/a |
|
|
Filter
vessels |
Carbon
replacement, £4,000 every five years |
800 |
n/a |
|
|
Chemical
savings |
Deozonisation
carbon removes free chlorine - extra chemical use |
1,000 |
|
|
|
Total
operation costs |
|
13,500 |
|
3,350 |
SAVING
PER YEAR 10, 150 |
Please note that only
full flow systems of each type are compared. Slipstream or bypass
systems, which cannot provide primary disinfection are not considered
suitable for professional systems.
|